Portola Pilot

Consumers Must Face the Truth of Unlocking Their Phones

Back to Article
Back to Article

Consumers Must Face the Truth of Unlocking Their Phones

Jane Zou, Staff Writer

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






As the use of facial recognition software infiltrates campuses, the privacy concern extends from just replacing identity cards to login methods for cell phones. Similar technology used to scan students’ faces to unlock campus gates has been accessible on mobile devices since its release in Japan in 2005 and its mainstream release in 2017 with Apple’s iPhoneX. Yet, facial recognition is a flawed, expensive system that effectively increases the price for smartphones and is a subject of controversy regarding the right to privacy protected by the Fourth and Fifth Amendments.

Facial recognition on phones currently consists of an infrared camera, dot projector and flood illuminator that recognizes the owner’s face even when obscured by accessories or cosmetics. As numerical passwords and fingerprints become increasingly common, facial recognition is the next wave of login method for electronic devices. However, what consumers trade for convenience, depending on their phone model, is the risk of easier break-ins by thieves or law enforcement.

According to an experiment conducted by Forbes, a 3D image of a head can unlock most Androids: an LG G7 ThinQ, a Samsung S9, a Samsung Note 8 and a OnePlus 6; the iPhoneX and Microsoft Windows Hello did not unlock with the head model.

Because Androids are often cheaper than Apple devices, it is inconclusive if the facial recognition itself is to blame for the malfunctions or if Androids have fewer login features to offer than Apple smartphones.

In criminal cases, the inability to open a suspect’s phone without the owner’s expressed permission can mean the difference between finding evidence of criminal activity and the suspect walking free. Companies Cellebrite and Grayshift are able to unlock iPhones without the passcode, and the Secret Service and Immigration Customs Enforcement (ICE) have invested millions of dollars into these companies’ services, according to Fortune. Within a few years, facial recognition may not be the safest login method compared to other biometric logins like iris or fingerprint scanning because of how accessible the phone’s contents are even with the lock.

With the current technology, the only way for facial recognition to be effective alone is to invest in an expensive mobile device upwards of $1,000, and the software can still malfunction. In combination with an alphanumeric or personal identification number (PIN) code, facial recognition has the potential to be the ultimate alternative to fingerprints and swiping, but what is a trend now can easily morph into the next security breach and identity theft.

Leave a Comment

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Left
  • Consumers Must Face the Truth of Unlocking Their Phones

    Opinion

    IUSD Does Not Need the AVID Program

  • Consumers Must Face the Truth of Unlocking Their Phones

    Opinion

    Running Up the Score is Hurting High School Sports

  • Consumers Must Face the Truth of Unlocking Their Phones

    Opinion

    Self-Studying for AP Tests: A Lucrative Option for Busy Students

  • Consumers Must Face the Truth of Unlocking Their Phones

    Opinion

    The DMV Should Be Revamped for Shorter Lines

  • Consumers Must Face the Truth of Unlocking Their Phones

    Opinion

    H2H: Should Sensitive Topics be the Subject of Debates in Schools?

  • Consumers Must Face the Truth of Unlocking Their Phones

    Opinion

    Improving the Junior Workshops

  • Consumers Must Face the Truth of Unlocking Their Phones

    Opinion

    Play your Part in Portola Pride: Every Student Can Raise School Spirit

  • Consumers Must Face the Truth of Unlocking Their Phones

    Opinion

    Staff Editorial: Wearing the Modern-Day Blindfold

  • Consumers Must Face the Truth of Unlocking Their Phones

    Opinion

    Bulldog Barks Can Get Too Loud

  • Consumers Must Face the Truth of Unlocking Their Phones

    Opinion

    Social Media Inflates Culture of ‘Victimhood Chic’

Navigate Right
The student news site of Portola High School
Consumers Must Face the Truth of Unlocking Their Phones