H2H: Can VAPA Requirements Expand Student Learning?
November 11, 2020
Mandatory VAPA Credits Set Students up for Success
Visual and performing arts credit has been a cornerstone of Portola High’s graduation requirements since the school’s founding in 2016. Although students whose passions lie elsewhere may balk at the notion of a mandatory VAPA course, this year-long commitment has proven fruitful to the greater student body regardless of their artistic background.
Students can choose from an array of courses – from orchestra to ceramics to studio art – and they have considerable flexibility in when they may take their courses. To graduate, students must complete two semesters’ worth of VAPA courses.
Portola’s mandatory VAPA requirements may also spur students to apply to schools in the University of California system. After all, UC schools require a year’s worth of VAPA credits to be eligible for admission, which fulfills the “F” requirement of their A-G subject admission requirements.
Apart from fulfilling requirements for university admission, students who enroll in VAPA courses also demonstrate greater academic achievement than their less artistically engaged peers, according to a report drawing conclusions from four longitudinal studies.
“This is my first year doing VAPA and I’m taking tech theater,” sophomore Colin Huang said. “It’s actually kind of interesting learning all the different aspects of how art is implemented in tech theater.”
These credit requirements not only bolster participation rates in performance groups like orchestras, bands and dance teams, but more importantly, large ensembles lend themselves to being greater than the sum of their parts, regardless of their level of experience.
“Everyone in [Dance 1] was kind of new to dance, so we were able to help each other learn,” junior Chloe Tjangnaka said.
A robust arts education has benefits that extend beyond the classroom. A 2014 study published in the Journal of Civil Society found that an arts education included promising outcomes like increased civic engagement and social tolerance. In addition, orchestra and band director Desmond Stevens found that the different expectations in his VAPA classes call for a proactive approach to learning.
“There’s definitely a level at which you have to do the preparation,” Stevens said. “You can’t just cram as some students are able to do with a history test or English test… You can’t cram notes; you can’t cram technique and just regurgitate it the next night.”
As future employers sorely need greater creativity, communication and critical thinking in an evolving workplace, it is essential to consider the role of VAPA courses as a means of fostering such skills while deepening an appreciation for the arts. Employers may not be assigning weekly instrumental recordings in twenty years, but students’ creative investments in high school now may set the groundwork for the innovative solutions of tomorrow.
Ryan Jung is excited for his first year writing for the Portola Pilot! He hopes to connect current events with his interests in public policy and philosophy...
VAPA Requirement Restricts Students from Finding True Passions
Like all Irvine Unified schools, Portola High students are required to earn credit for at least one year of visual and performing arts to graduate, ultimately requiring some students to take a class they do not have passion for, rather than adding more classes and courses to be counted as VAPA that students would prefer to take.
Current freshmen, sophomore, and juniors who have not completed their VAPA credit must do so by taking Fundamentals of Art over the summer at San Joaquin High, participating in musicals throughout the school year or taking a listed art class on Portola’s course catalog during their senior year.
With the pandemic’s unpredictability and the few cases of seniors who need to complete the requirement to be A-G eligible, it is challenging for the counselors to scramble to have them enrolled in a course to fit their schedule.
“I think that my VAPA class is inhibiting me from taking other electives that I would have enjoyed taking instead,” junior Sara Amini said. “I wanted to double up on sciences or even take another medical-related ROP class, which can help me a lot in the future with college and future career, but since I had not completed my VAPA credits, I was enrolled into ceramics.”
A student who is enrolled in a sport, world language, core classes and an extra elective that interests them would be unable to fit a VAPA class into their schedule.
Not only does it create scheduling interferences , but it inhibits students from taking elective classes that could benefit them or their GPA, especially optional core subjects such as AP Chemistry or AP Biology.
Because of the limited VAPA classes in the requirement, students are forced to spend at least one year in a class that could ultimately have no effect on their future, rather than IUSD adding more VAPA courses in which students are more passionate about.
Emma Haag is the new 2020-2021 Sports Editor! It is her second year as a part of the Portola Pilot, and she is more than thrilled to see what the new year...
Kayla Moshayedi is a new addition to our Portola Pilot Staff and is beyond excited to share her new ideas and thoughts. She is thankful to be apart of...